
Many writers ask: “Why go through a round of developmental editing?” It can be confusing and unclear to truly understand what a developmental book editor does and how they can provide book writing tips to improve your book. One example is that a developmental editor can help you draft stronger, more impactful scenes. They may not provide feedback on every scene, but for the key moments in the book (such as The Ordeal that the protagonist faces at the end of Act 2), having a developmental editor pay close attention to the strength of that scene can enhance the overall story.
Why Focus on Individual Scenes?
Your novel is made up of scenes, the same way a movie is made up of scenes. Characters interacting. Dialogue and action that represent different tensions and the resolution of those tensions. If a novel is heavy on narration – always explaining to the reader what is going on rather than letting them interpret the events for themselves – the reader may get bored. (This is where a developmental edit or finding book writing tips on narration can prove useful by pointing out these instances!) But no matter how much telling versus showing is going on in your scene, there are key questions to ask to help you ensure that each scene is complete and contributes to the plot of your novel as a whole.
11 Questions to Ask to Determine What Is and Isn’t Working in a Scene
1. Who is the Protagonist?
Who or what is the protagonist in this scene? Which character is the one your reader should be focusing on? (In the event that you have several main characters, or that the scene is being shown from a supporting character’s POV, the reader should be clear who is the focus of the scene and whose side they are on.) Focusing on this can help you avoid the dreaded “head-hopping” (switching character POVs midscene). A developmental book editor can help locate any instances of head-hopping that you may have glossed over.
2. Who is the Antagonist?
Who, or what, is the antagonist in this scene? Who or what is taking action to prevent your main character (protagonist) from achieving their ultimate goal? It should be clear in each scene what opposing forces are at play.
3. What does the Protagonist want to do?
The protagonist’s goal in the scene may be separate from their larger goal or a part of it. Let’s say your protagonist’s main goal is to save their sister, who has been kidnapped by the antagonist. Every scene in the plot should contribute toward their (eventual, hopeful) achievement of that goal. But in a scene where the protagonist has to gain information from a side character so they can continue on their journey, the protagonist’s goal in the scene is more precise: It’s not “save Sis!”, it’s “find out X so I can save Sis!”
So in a particular scene, the protagonist simply wants to talk to the side character to find out what they need to know. Integrating these into every scene can be tricky, so the developmental edit can help you better define the goal in each scene. It’s best to think of the straightforward goal as a producer of several obstacles blocking the protagonist from achieving said goal.
4. What does the Antagonist want to do?
You’ve probably heard several book writing tips stating that in every scene, your protagonist should want something, even if it’s as simple as a glass of water. That may be easy, as your protagonist has a central goal they’re working to achieve throughout the entire plot. However, don’t forget your antagonist.
If your antagonist only wants to “stop the protagonist!” in every scene, that will become boring and repetitive/predictable for the reader. A well-rounded antagonist should have their own goals and aims throughout the novel, and in each scene, their actions should reflect movement toward that goal, as much as your protagonist’s actions should reflect movement toward their goal.
5. What emotion will the reader experience?
What are you trying to evoke in the reader throughout the scene? What is the protagonist feeling and how will that translate to the reader’s experience of the scene and contribute to their experience of the novel as a whole? If you find yourself stuck on this one, pull from your own experiences to channel the emotion you wish to convey. A developmental book editor can also provide a second set of eyes on if these emotional beats are effective or not.
6. What is the inciting incident for the scene?
It could be something as simple as someone telling the protagonist that X person has the information they need, which sends the protagonist on a visit to X’s house to ask them what they know. Or it could be something as complicated as solving an ancient riddle that triggers an elaborate booby trap protecting the tomb in which the protagonist is standing. Whatever it is, make sure it’s clear to the reader how the character ended up in the situation in which they now find themselves.
7. What is the turning point of the scene?
There are helpful book writing tips for common shifts in pivotal scenes – the protagonist learns something new; someone changes their mind; the door clicks open. Make sure it’s clear to the reader where in the scene the action moves toward the next plot point or emotional moment. A developmental book editor can help smoothen your turning point transitions into the next scene.
8. What is the crisis of the scene?
What is the tensest moment of the scene for the protagonist? The moment when there is no turning back? Often, this is the most heightened emotional moment for your reader as well, but sometimes the most emotional moment comes immediately after the crisis. See if you can identify exactly where in the scene the characters are at their most tense or most strained.
9. What is the climax of the scene?
How does the tension of the scene come to a head? Is there a moment when the tension has been ramped up so much it can’t be turned up any more? Not every scene needs to be a grand climax for the story, but several book writing tips state that having each scene reach a peak ensures its purpose and meaningful transition to the next scene.
10. What is the result/resolution of the scene?
Did the protagonist get what they wanted? Did the antagonist? Did both of them walk away without gaining progress toward their goal, or are they sent in a new direction to find out more? Or was the tension interrupted and neither of them got what they wanted, only motivating them more for the next confrontation?
11. Who "won" the scene?
Sometimes, the protagonist gets what they wanted out of the scene. Sometimes, the antagonist does. Even if the antagonist is a disembodied force — such as “society” or “family pressure” — sometimes, the protagonist will confront something within themselves and wrestle with these disembodied forces, and come up short. (A developmental edit can be useful for properly utilizing these forces.) They may not be able to “defeat” this antagonist yet; they may still be caught up in complications that result in them continuing to struggle against these forces. Sometimes, the antagonist wins so that the protagonist can keep on fighting.
Developmental Editors Provide Book Writing Tips

For key scenes throughout the novel, the developmental book editor can provide focused feedback to help you make the most of your revision time and to address these questions and point out where (and maybe how) scenes could be strengthened by addressing some of these questions so the reader has full context and a complete emotional experience every time it matters.
This information was elaborated on from book writing tips provided in a 2026 webinar hosted by Tim Grahl, CEO of Story Grid, titled “Why Draft-First Thinking Keeps Writers Stuck.” Story Grid offers book writing mentorship for writers of all levels. SRD Editing Services editor Cortni Merritt attended the webinar as part of her commitment to ongoing education in developmental editing and book coaching.









The questions around what it “should” cost to edit a book are always a bit tricky. The answer will be unique to you, your project, and your team, and it depends on several important factors.
Planners, or “architects,” are writers who thrive on structure. Here are some tips for new writers who want to take this meticulous approach:
Pantsers, or “gardeners,” revel in the thrill of uncertainty. Here are some tips for new writers who find that this spontaneous approach works best for them:
Included also in the cost to publish a book are the visual elements, pictures, graphics, and other details that contribute to the look and presentation of the finished product. Design costs include the creation of art and organizing the layout of both the book’s interior and exterior. This means the book’s front cover, spine, and back cover, as well as a book jacket if you’re publishing a hardcover book. Then of course, the text must be laid out and formatted.









